In re Ferguson
The Federal Circuit will decide whether a pure business method is patentable

On December 5, 2007, I argued "In re Ferguson" at the Federal Circuit.  That case considers the subject matter patentability of a pure business method claim.

The main brief

The Patent Office's rebuttal

The reply brief

 If you're an AIPLA member, you can read a synopsis of the argument here

 

Back to main page

Ferguson's appealed claim 1

1.         A method of marketing a product, comprising:            developing a shared marketing force, said shared marketing force including at least marketing channels, which enable marketing a number of related products;

            using said shared marketing force to market a plurality of different products that are made by a plurality of different autonomous producing company, so that different autonomous companies, having different ownerships, respectively produce said related products;             obtaining a share of total profits from each of said plurality of different autonomous producing companies in return for said using; and             obtaining an exclusive right to market each of said plurality of products in return for said using.